Geogram library alternative for 3D Boolean Operations
In the realm of computational geometry, 3D boolean operations play a crucial role in various applications, from CAD modeling to 3D printing. Selecting the right library for these operations can significantly impact efficiency and accuracy. In this article, we compare two prominent libraries, MeshLib and Geogram, to provide insights into their performance and suitability for real-world scenarios.
What is MeshLib?
MeshLib is an open-source 3D geometry library renowned for its versatility and ease of use. Supporting both C++ and Python, MeshLib simplifies complex geometric tasks, making it a preferred choice across industries.
What is Geogram Library?
Geogram is a powerful programming library containing geometric algorithms developed as part of the former ALICE Inria project. Backed by over 30 research articles published in leading journals and supported by grants from the European Research Council, Geogram is highly regarded for its advanced geometric processing capabilities.
MeshLib vs Geogram Comparison results
Nefertiti Case
This scenario involves a large mesh (4M Triangles) with complex topology, representing a common challenge in 3D boolean operations.
Before
After
Library | MeshLib | Geogram Library |
|---|---|---|
Time (seconds) | 1.621 | 41.188 |
Time Ratio (MeshLib/Geogram) | 1 | 25.409 |
Success | TRUE | TRUE |
Issues | NO | NO |
Dental Case
In this case, we simulate dental models (500K Triangles) with degeneracies and coinciding surfaces, reflecting real-world scenarios encountered in medical applications.
Before
After
Library | MeshLib | Geogram Library |
|---|---|---|
Time (seconds) | 0.296 | 6.375 |
Time Ratio (MeshLib/Geogram) | 1 | 21.537 |
Success | TRUE | TRUE |
Issues | NO | Holes (possibly non-manifold) |
Testing Setup
- Operating System: Windows 11
- CPU: Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-10870H @ 2.20GHz
- RAM: 16GB
- GPU: NVIDIA GeForce
- RTX 3070 Laptop
- GPU/PCIe/SSE2
To download the comparison data for MeshLib and Geogram Library, please visit the following link.
Why choose MeshLib SDK for 3D boolean operations over Geogram?
In both the Nefertiti and Dental cases, MeshLib outperformed Geogram Library in terms of processing time. While both libraries successfully completed the operations without issues in the Dental case, Geogram Library encountered potential non-manifold issues when dealing with holes. Overall, MeshLib demonstrates superior performance and reliability in these scenarios, making it a promising alternative for 3D boolean operations.